Did you find what you were looking for?

The Wine Skinny is adding new features with every issue. Let us know what you'd like to see!

 

April/May 2008

Restaurant Review: Charlie Trotter's, Chicago

There was a time that multiple-course menus of artfully arranged and inventively prepared food was a novelty. Something you couldn't get much of anywhere. And it was exciting - you'd never seen a foam sauce before. Or a lamb chop that tiny with the bone scraped pearly white. Layered caviar and avocado mousse in a cordial glass seemed extraordinary. Enjoying the endless parade of courses paired with wines you'd never heard of was fascinating and a one-of-a-kind experience.

Those days are well behind us, it seems. These days, every chef who grows a touch tired of the daily routine thinks he or she can whip up a tasting menu worthy of fetching the big bucks. Prix fixe menus have become a tired march of unsatisfying weirdness on a plate.

And we're pretty well sick of 'em.

Until an evening at Charlie Trotter's reminds us of why this man is considered one of the true, and few, real geniuses in the kitchen.

One recent evening there, we reveled in that night's Grand Tasting Menu, an artful celebration of exquisitely prepared courses that hit just the right notes. Portions are perfect - not too dainty to enjoy, but specifically sized to allow all the courses to shine. A seared scallop was served with a delicious sweet potato ravioli and drizzled in a smoked bacon jus. Savory, satisfying bites (about 4, by the way) with great texture and taste. Nothing fussy the whole night.

Another course featured leek confit with fennel and a local sheeps' milk cheese. Just rich enough, quite satisfying, it left us wanting just a touch more - the perfect place to be when there are multiple courses still on the way.

Charlie Trotter's is definitely one of the very few places where we're happy to leave the wine selection to the master. Different wines - judicious pours, to be sure, but not skimpy - arrived with each course. From Tocai to Riesling to Pinot Noir, we had a great time rating our favorites and contemplating the food match.

This is a place to really revel in the experience of a well-done tasting menu. Where you can sit back and enjoy the ride, letting the artistry wash over you in waves of culinary pleasure. The room is relaxed and quiet. Service is unobtrusive without being snobby.

Charlie Trotter's is perfect for people who want to splurge on a new dining experience - and also for those, like us, who need our faith renewed in a tasting menu. The Grand Menu is $135 per person; adding wines for each course is an additional $85 per person. There is also a Vegetable Menu (which looked awfully tempting, both on the page and at the table next to us!) for $115 per person. And the granddaddy Kitchen Tasting Menu at $175 per person. (october 2005)

Charlie Trotter's
816 W Armitage Ave
Chicago, IL 60614-4308
(773) 248-6228
www.charlietrotters.com

 

The Wine Skinny is a publication of Tinsley Public Relations, LLC
Privacy Statement • Copyright © 1998-2008